A) Number of children. Having children is protective against breast cancer; in
fact, the more children, the higher the protection. One study found that women who have
seven or more children had a 47% less chance of developing the disease than women who'd
had only one child. This probably has to do with the fact that with more children a woman
has less menstrual periods, thus less up- and-down estrogen fluctuations.
B) Breast-feeding. The function of a woman's breasts is to secrete milk for her
newborn, especially if she has actually been pregnant. Pregnancy initiates changes in the
breasts, preparing them for lactation. If that process is interrupted or not allowed to
proceed, through miscarriage or by bottle feeding, the body has to deal with the
aftermath. Plugged milk ducts can result in lumps; while these would start off generally
benign, over time, with other risk factors, they could become cancerous. In fact, all
breast cancers arise in the milk ducts. Short breast-feeding has not shown any protective
effect; what counts is the accumulated time of breast-feeding during the whole of a
woman's life. In the study mentioned, women with a lifetime total of 25 or more months of
breast-feeding had a 33% lower risk for contracting breast cancer as compared to women
with natural children who had never breast-fed. I will assume that suppressing lactation
with drugs can also have serious adverse effects on the breast.
C) Environmental causes. There are a number of external factors that may affect
a woman's hormonal health. The main ones are pesticides, particularly organochlorides, and
living near nuclear reactors. Many petroleum-based pesticides imitate the form of
estrogen, and confuse the body into accepting them into their cells. They are sprayed on
fruits, vegetables, and animal feed; when these are consumed, the pesticides then are
stored in human and animal fat, which, according to Connecticut nutritionist Phyllis
Herman, may explain the link between a high animal fat diet and breast cancer. A 1990
study in Israel found a strong link: between 1976 and 1986, the rate of breast cancer
declined 20% after a number of organochlorine-type pesticides were banned. Industrial
countries where breast cancer mortality declined between 1971 and 1986 had no large
commercial nuclear reactors operating within or near their borders; the other 12
industrial powers did, and breast cancer rose in them all. It is thought that low-level
radioactive contamination enters the groundwater, affecting produce, and is also carried
downwind, affecting both animals and people. These environmental reasons are perhaps why
breast cancer mortality rates for Long Island went up 39% between 1970 and 1989.
D) Use of antiperspirants. Here is a very intriguing thought. Kerri Bodner,
publisher of the excellent Women's Health Letter, points out that 50% of breast cancer
tumors appear on the upper quadrant of the breast closest to the underarm. Antiperspirants
are strong chemicals, usually containing aluminum, which prevent sweating. Now sweating is
a way for the body to eliminate toxins and unwanted materials with the help of the
lymphatic system. Preventing this activity is, in Bodner's words, "like damming up a
river." Sweat backs up into the lymphatic ducts, and the toxins become trapped in the
under-arm lymphatic area. The fatty breast tissue allows for efficient storage of these
unwanted toxins. Breast cancer often involves the lymph nodes. Could there be a
connection?
E) Tight and underwire bras. I remember reading an article that pointed out an
increased risk of breast cancer for women who used tight bras, particularly if they wore
them for more than 12 hours. Tight bras also interfere with breathing, which may in turn
cause oxygen deprivation in the cells. I personally have great antipathy to underwire
bras: the metal in them crosses the body's acupuncture meridians, and so can block the
normal flow of Chi which in turn can cause stagnation and disease. Why do women through
the ages feel they have to mold themselves into some shape dictated by social whim?
F) The use of oral contraceptives. Numerous studies have shown the direct
correlation between hormone-based drugs and female cancers. The latest is a study
published in The Lancet, the prestigious British medical journal, on the effects of The
Pill on 150,000 women. It found that all users face an increased risk, even 10 years after
stopping. Women on the Pill had a 25% higher risk of contracting breast cancer. A study in
1994 had found that women who started on the Pill before the age of 20 had a 3 ½ times
higher risk, while 97% of the women who got cancer before the age of 36 had used birth
control pills at one time or another of their lives. Note that this does NOT mean that 97%
of the women who took birth control pills got cancer; it's the other way around. Obviously
there are other variables triggering the disease.
G) Diet. Fat is suspect, but studies give conflicting results and the issue is
not conclusive. It is often mentioned that Japanese women eating their traditional low-fat
diets have little if any breast cancer, but when they come to the US they soon catch up. I
maintain that fat is not the issue: milk products are. The Japanese diet has no milk
products, but now that they are picking up "Western" dietary habits, their use
of these products is going up and so is their breast cancer. The highest rates of the
disease are in Northern Europe (Finland, Sweden, Holland), the UK, the US, and Canada --
all countries where cow's milk is a major food. Frequent consumption of whole milk has
been found to be a risk factor in cancers of the lung, bladder, breast, and cervix; even
more interesting, breast cancer patients were found to have twice as high a consumption of
Vitamin D (usually added to milk) as cancer-free controls.
What foods protect against cancer? Cruciferous vegetables clearly do: cabbage,
broccoli, cauliflower, Brussels sprouts, kale, kohlrabi. Soybeans have also been
developing a good reputation as anti-cancer foods. Miso and tofu are excellent additions
to your diet. Here is a simple recipe.
MISO- TOFU SPREAD
½ block soft tofu, steamed for 3 minutes and cooled (about 5 oz)
1 tablespoon brown rice or barley miso
1 tablespoon flaxseed or extra virgin olive oil
2 tablespoons grated onion
Mash all the ingredients together in a bowl, and serve on
wholegrain bread or rye crackers.